KeepUp
DirectoryCalendarAbout UsContact
Filters
KeepUp

Find your next favorite card shop.

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Shop by state
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2026 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

KeepUp
DirectoryCalendarAbout UsContact
Filters
KeepUp

Find your next favorite card shop.

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Shop by state
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2026 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

KeepUp

177 trading card game shops matching your criteria

Browse by state

Kaleido TCG

Kaleido TCG

4.5(34 reviews)
Jersey City, NJ

Visited yesterday and while I didn't buy anything I was super impressed with the selection and presentation. Their sealed product stock is amazing, including recent release and sought after sets from the last few years. I asked about prices and they look them up on the fly, which is great! Wish I was local so I could spend more time here! Props to the owner for this gem.

Online Store
Kessler's Corner

Kessler's Corner

5(18 reviews)
Garwood, NJ

Get set up with a new domain name right away. Affordable payment plans to fit any budget. Friendly customer support.

Online Store
Kill Screen Games

Kill Screen Games

4.7(246 reviews)
Asbury Park, NJ

It was a nice little store inside of an Arcade, reminded me a lot of Pike Place Market in Seattle except with much more interesting stores, like this one. The store was fairly small but space was used well, pretty much had the best games from every generation of console from the NES to the Switch 2, and they kept all their games in really excellent condition. My biggest complaint by far is the price. Trade ins are fair enough, you’ll get maybe 70% of their value and I can understand that. But man some of those games are WAY out of line, some games are at a 50% to 100% markup of what you can find online. Just like landmines sitting on the shelves you gotta dodge around when shopping. Now I always understand you gotta pay rent and employees and power bills not to mention taking care of yourself. I expect to pay higher prices than online, but I think $40 for Mario Golf Toadstool tour is pushing it. I still managed to find some good deals at the end of the day though, got some games for a fair price and I’m happy with that. Just keep in mind some of these games will blindside you with their prices.

Online Store
KMTV Trading Cards

KMTV Trading Cards

4.1(57 reviews)
Fair Lawn, NJ

We spark meaningful dialogue, empower creativity, and turn ideas into real-world impact across our global community. Our global community continues to inspire us as we continue creating innovative opportunities that reward and empower them - on and beyond our platform. Whether we're introducing new features or building on the products you love, we’re passionate about earning the trust of our community.

Online Store
Koros Wargames

Koros Wargames

4.8(70 reviews)
Flemington, NJ

Koros Wargames is a gem of a store. I can’t believe it’s taken me this long to write a review! They are my go to stop for my painting and hobby products. They have so much to offer from a variety of paint brands like AK interactive and Citadel. Plus a large selection of miniatures, model kits, TCGS, and a wide selection of different Wargames. The staff here are also super friendly and always open to chat about gaming or your latest hobby projects. Each product recommendation I’ve tried here has kept me going back for more. They also have a very active Discord server where you can find people to game with or show off your latest painting projects. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area but also worth the trek if you’re coming from far away.

Online Store
Lacey Cardsmart

Lacey Cardsmart

4.6(33 reviews)
Lacey Township, NJ

Online Store
Liquid Games

Liquid Games

4.9(55 reviews)
Ocean Township, NJ

We're your local hub for all things Pokémon. Whether you're a seasoned player or a dedicated collector, there's something here for you. At Liquid Games, our passion for the hobby shines through in everything we do, and the amazing community we've built is proof of that. Stop by and be part of the excitement; we can't wait to see you!

Online Store
Luke and Cade's Toy Chest (The Nerd Mall)

Luke and Cade's Toy Chest (The Nerd Mall)

4.6(78 reviews)
Woodbury, NJ

Home to everything Nerdy, Geeky, and just plain Fun

Online Store
Main Street Comics & Toys

Main Street Comics & Toys

4.8(494 reviews)
Milltown, NJ

New Jersey comic book shop Main Street Comics in Milltown, New Jersey. We buy & sell comics, toys & collectibles.

Online Store
Manifest Comics

Manifest Comics

4.7(224 reviews)
Bayonne, NJ

The worker was very nice and gave my younger sister a free plush is a great local spot for all comic needs and trading cards. I was shocked they had the newest pokemon packs in stocks as well! Shop was very nice as well. I almost walked out with half the store.

Online Store
Maplewood Hobby

Maplewood Hobby

4.6(200 reviews)
Maplewood, NJ

Twice a year, Maplewood Hobby hosts an auction that offers amazing bargains for aficionados of military miniatures and war games. On Friday nights, the store stays open late to host groups of Battletech and Warhammer gamers. How do I know all this? I have a husband who grew up with these interests, and now he has shared them with our son. It turns out that all I had to do to get my kid excited about family fencing practice was join a club around the corner from the premier gaming store in New Jersey.

Online Store
Millennium Hobbies & The Gundam Kitchen

Millennium Hobbies & The Gundam Kitchen

4.9(249 reviews)
Gloucester Township, NJ

Online Store
Mom and Pop Shop Collectibles LLC

Mom and Pop Shop Collectibles LLC

4.6(34 reviews)
Bayonne, NJ

Supporting a family-owned business run by a fellow Bayonne native is always a pleasure! This place truly has something special- an amazing community vibe, events that bring people together, and an extensive candy and drink selection. For fans of Magic: The Gathering and other in-person games, it's such a refreshing reminder of how fun it is to play face-to-face in a world that often forgets that feeling. I love Mom and Pop Shop Collectibles, and I'm so glad Bayonne has a place like this!

Online Store
Monmouth Trading Cards

Monmouth Trading Cards

4.9(273 reviews)
East Brunswick, NJ

Monmouth Trading Cards is an outstanding shop! From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted by Johnathan, whose enthusiasm made us feel immediately welcome. His knowledge of card trading is impressive, and he took the time to answer our questions while teaching us a lot during our visit. The level of customer service here is truly top-notch, professional, friendly, and genuinely passionate about trading cards. I highly recommend Monmouth Trading Cards to both beginners and seasoned collectors.

Online Store
Monmouth Trading Cards

Monmouth Trading Cards

5(475 reviews)
Midland Park, NJ

Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collectors who want more than just cards.

Online Store
  • Previous
  • 1
  • More pages
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • More pages
  • 12
  • Next
Filters