5959 trading card game shops
One of the nicest cross stitch stores I have ever been in. They have a huge selection of fabric, threads and accessories. The staff is knowledgeable and will work with you to order whatever you need. I needed cloth that was used in a project that was used in 2020 and incredibly the owner tracked some down and ordered it. Very reasonably priced on everything you need. Please help support our local small businesses. I travel 45 minutes to get to this shop and it is time well spent. The shop is very clean every time I have been there. I just cannot recommend this shop enough.
Cute toy/game shop in North Lake! My husband and I wanted to pick out a few fun games to play at our cabin and got “Tenzi” and a Tahoe deck of cards. The lady who helped us was friendly and we are happy with our purchase.
Shop Villains TCG for Pokémon, One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and MTG cards. Fair prices. Fast shipping. Trusted by collectors.
This is a great store and the staff are amazing. They special ordered some books for me, and I got exactly what I wanted. I cannot recommend checking them out enough. Its a truly great local games store, not something you see much of anymore.
Vintage sports memorabilia with a focus on Indiana High School Basketball, Indianapolis Colts, Indiana Pacers, Indiana University, Purdue University, Notre Dame, Vintage and Modern Baseball, Basketball, Football, and Hockey Cards.
Finally getting back into comics after too many years of neglecting them. This shop has been such a fun place for me to go and explore. Reasonable prices, great selection (especially for a smaller store), and the staff is always really personable and helpful. Plus, I always love supporting a local business. I seriously love this place and am so glad it's helping me get back into comics again :)
Honestly, Terrible. I walked in at 6:15 pm when they close at 7PM. I had gathered maybe 7-8 things I was wanted to sell to them (a mixture of blue rays and ps3 games). I was greeted at the door and asked if I needed help and asked him what the could do for these items. He immediately sighed loudly then said “one second” then walked away. Maybe 5 minutes goes by then he comes back and says “you’re gonna have to come back tomorrow, we have a policy that we can’t do trades this close to closing the store”. It wasn’t even the fact he asked me to come back the next day. It was the audible sigh and way he went about it. Even if there is a policy why wouldn’t he tell me that at the beginning? He waited after he was clearly unhappy I was in there before saying anything about it. After 20+ years of trading, buying, and selling there I’ve never felt compelled to leave a review until now. Didn’t realize I had to show up 2-3 hours before closing to use one of your stores main core functions of revenue. PS it was the tall redhead dude.
Vintage Stock is an alright store, but like other retro stores it'll be a hit or miss or rare chance of finding what your looking for. It's very well organized and has tons of options. Only problem I have is the pricing for a good chuck of it, movies/games being pretty steep even when there not that rare. Vintage Stock trades are also ok but seems like low balling pretty often, even when you have a bundle of something brand new in the box and only offering 12$ and then high pricing it later. There was a time I found a copy of Halo 2 aluminum case, it was bent and couldn't close, I asked if they would do a discount, and said they couldn't when the product is damaged clearly and already steep price. It's not a bad store, just has its cons and pros. Great for browsing or getting lucky finding that one rare item or such. Restrooms in the back and front is wheel chair accessible
At Vintage Toy Traders, we buy, sell, and trade vintage toys, comics and some modern toys. Come visit the store and take a walk down memory lane!
