Trip Review 15.5( 16 but I like the name better ). All American Cards and Comics – Boardman, OH (52 Boardman Canfield Rd.) Greg’s 2nd location. All American Cards and Comics in Boardman is a fantastic extension of the Warren location—think of it less as a carbon copy and more like Warren’s little brother with its own distinct charm. Housed in a convenient strip mall, it’s a bit more compact, but that actually works in its favor. The layout is streamlined, clean, and incredibly well-organized, making it easy to browse whether you’re hunting for back issues, the latest comics, Magic: The Gathering singles, or gaming supplies. While it may not have the same size as the Warren location, this shop holds its own with a focused selection and top-notch customer service. Every major purchase I’ve made from owner Greg Bartholomew has come from this very store, and the quality has always been outstanding. Most recently, I picked up a pristine copy of All-Star Comics featuring the first appearance of Power Girl. One major highlight is the adjacent gaming annex. Instead of cramming tables into the retail space, they’ve dedicated a separate area next door for gaming. This keeps the main store open, easy to navigate, and free of clutter—perfect for collectors and casual browsers alike. Whether you’re a Magic player looking for rare cards, a comic collector searching for that elusive issue, or just someone who appreciates a well-run local shop, this location is definitely worth a visit. And don’t forget—they’re always buying Magic cards and comics too, so bring your extras! Greg Bartholomew
I visited this location while visiting a friend. The location offered a good selection of singles and sealed MTG product. The staff was helpful and the experience was positive overall. The best part, was the MTG commander league that I managed to sit in on, it was fun, friendly, and inviting. I'd recommend anyone to visit of in the area and wanting to pick up a new set or play against cool locals in MTG.
Great store. Wide selection of gaming and comics. Great prices too. Staff is helpful and friendly. Definitely going back as much as my wife will let me 😁
Trip Review 15.5( 16 but I like the name better ). All American Cards and Comics – Boardman, OH (52 Boardman Canfield Rd.) Greg’s 2nd location. All American Cards and Comics in Boardman is a fantastic extension of the Warren location—think of it less as a carbon copy and more like Warren’s little brother with its own distinct charm. Housed in a convenient strip mall, it’s a bit more compact, but that actually works in its favor. The layout is streamlined, clean, and incredibly well-organized, making it easy to browse whether you’re hunting for back issues, the latest comics, Magic: The Gathering singles, or gaming supplies. While it may not have the same size as the Warren location, this shop holds its own with a focused selection and top-notch customer service. Every major purchase I’ve made from owner Greg Bartholomew has come from this very store, and the quality has always been outstanding. Most recently, I picked up a pristine copy of All-Star Comics featuring the first appearance of Power Girl. One major highlight is the adjacent gaming annex. Instead of cramming tables into the retail space, they’ve dedicated a separate area next door for gaming. This keeps the main store open, easy to navigate, and free of clutter—perfect for collectors and casual browsers alike. Whether you’re a Magic player looking for rare cards, a comic collector searching for that elusive issue, or just someone who appreciates a well-run local shop, this location is definitely worth a visit. And don’t forget—they’re always buying Magic cards and comics too, so bring your extras! Greg Bartholomew
52 Boardman-Canfield Road
Boardman, OH 44512
United States
Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.
