KeepUp
About UsContact
Bethany Sports Cards Plus

Bethany Sports Cards Plus

4.1
(294 reviews)

My husband and I were in earlier today while on a weekend trip to my parents beach house. We were having a "pokemon Friday" and stumbled upon this gem of a store! They had the absolute best selection of pokemon cards we've seen in quite some time. The selection of alternate art pokemon was out of this world, even a few mega ex pokemon! Prices were excellent and the selection of booster packs on display were fantastic! Additionally, the workers in the store were extremely personable and kind, you can tell they want repeat customers and enjoy making customers happy. Thank you for treating us as if we were locals, we will definitely be back!! Oh, and I almost forgot, they made my husband a cup of espresso while we shopped!

Online Store
Games Available
PokemonSports
Opening Hours
Friday9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Monday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
KeepUp

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2025 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

Thursday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Customer Reviews
Heather Mox11/1/2025

My husband and I were in earlier today while on a weekend trip to my parents beach house. We were having a "pokemon Friday" and stumbled upon this gem of a store! They had the absolute best selection of pokemon cards we've seen in quite some time. The selection of alternate art pokemon was out of this world, even a few mega ex pokemon! Prices were excellent and the selection of booster packs on display were fantastic! Additionally, the workers in the store were extremely personable and kind, you can tell they want repeat customers and enjoy making customers happy. Thank you for treating us as if we were locals, we will definitely be back!! Oh, and I almost forgot, they made my husband a cup of espresso while we shopped!

Erik Johnson
Van Bavel Bros
Contact Information

123 Garfield Parkway

Bethany Beach, DE 19930

United States

(302) 537-6330
Visit Website
Follow:

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.

10/23/2025

Went down for first time. Was greeted and staff was very friendly. I was trading a few pokemon cards in for store credit and they were more than fair. Highly recomend. I live in millsboro and definitely plan on going in more even though its a drive. Prices are pretty decent. With it being so hard to find pokemon cards at the moment its worth the couple dollars more. Glad to say this will ne my go to for pokemon. They have other stuff as well!

10/19/2025

In customer facing businesses, aside from product, experience is everything. The interactions between buyer and seller are key to repeat business and referrals. This was our second time in the store and Max, the owner, remembered a conversation from earlier in the summer months ago. That kind of attention is memorable and a differentiator. We’re happy to support this local small business and appreciate the thoughtfulness and attention given to each guest! While Pokémon is our thing, the store also carries baseball and other sports memorabilia. The Pokémon selection is great having packs of several sets at market price, but the real gold is in their singles. TONS of slabs (graded cards) and cards from $1-30+ in top loaders too! Thanks again and see ya next time ✌️