KeepUp
About UsContact
Cardboard Coliseum

Cardboard Coliseum

4.4
(26 reviews)

I’ve been into the gaming scene for many years, whether it’s TCG or Tabletop. I’ve played in professional circuits for both as well as having experience hosting plenty of events for both public and charity. I am also a founding creator of a 350+ people community that connects people within the entire state of WV and surrounding areas to local game stores throughout. With our goal to encourage friendly and welcoming environments. My knowledge and experience should hold merit to what I am about to say. Cardboard Coliseum is one of the most welcoming and friendly stores I have ever had the pleasure of going to. The store owner here is nothing short of an honest and good person with the upmost respect from everyone who visits his store and gets to meet him. The store is a clean, and comfortable environment with plenty of space for gaming. I have had the pleasure to not only meet but play with the local players here. They are an amazing player base, everybody is so welcoming and ready to help new players. This is a rare thing to find in today. Tucked away in a beautifully quiet little town with a very interesting history just dead center of the state. This is for sure on of my top recommendations to stop at. So much so that I regularly drive here over an hour away weekly to play with friends and family as it’s a great halfway place for all of us. Now…. These one star reviews you see… These were made by players looking to prey upon small communities and scalp rare event cards away from them, only so they can turn a profit for greed . They would much rather think about themselves and destroy a small community. They decided to scalp from another store first and race to this one to do the very same. Making an excuse to extend the start of a tournament, the owner decided to welcome them and extend the start time, but clearly, professionally, and politely told them no later. These two players, then proceeded to try and argue for another extension, even to the point of eluding directions and roping him along on the phone trying to delay the event yet again. He extended yet again. They showed up after the delay and continued to try and argue their way into the event after it started. Once he stuck to his word and the rules of the event.They proceeded to hurt a local small business owner by falsely accusing the store of being unprofessional and unclean through their bad reviews… This is a disgusting display of the toxicity plaguing the gaming communities and shouldn’t be welcome anywhere. To Cardboard Coliseum- Thank you so much for providing the environment that you do and the player base that you have.

Online Store
Games Available
Flesh and BloodLorcanaPokemonStar Wars UnlimitedYu-Gi-Oh!
KeepUp

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2025 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

Opening Hours
Friday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
MondayClosed
Sunday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Customer Reviews
Rebekah9/24/2025

The absolute BEST game shop in WV. Inclusive and accepting. This shop isn't a "boy's club" like many and welcomes girl gamers. Love it!

Manny Arambula
Caitlin Stout
Contact Information

203 2nd Street

Sutton, WV 26601

United States

(336) 686-7224
13e49d785d8d4f828038b6136f3b48ba@sentry.io
Visit Website

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.

8/25/2025

Best game store I have been in for a long time!! Friendly and helpful.

4/21/2024

This is one of the best gaming stores that the state of West Virginia has to offer, no questions. I drive an hour away almost weekly to spend time here. Everyone is always friendly and welcoming, which is very important to me because I have really bad social anxiety and am relatively new to gaming. I am a proud customer and can’t recommend this store enough.