KeepUp
About UsContact
Cardcollector2 Sports Cards

Cardcollector2 Sports Cards

4.9
(1127 reviews)

Update: Given their response, I visited them again, and I do not think anything was improved. I did not see interesting cards in the showcase(mostly locals, like a Donovan Mitchell insert for $30), and sealed products had unreasonable prices (like $15 for a single pack of prismatic evolutions). In my view, the strengths of a local card store should be offering better prices than online and giving customers the freedom to choose their own boxes. Unfortunately, this store does neither. Hopefully they genuinely consider improving,. Being a well-known 'hype shop' is not an excuse for overlooking what really matters to local customers. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Store was remodeled with a great design so decided to stop by. Environment - The store is clean and well-organized and I really like it. Many showcases inside grouped by sports/Pokemon. There's a big Pokemon showcase, which looks cool. Singles Selection - Since I am a follower of Ryan's Youtube Channel and their social medias, I always found them buying cards and selling online. However, when I go to the store, I do not find many interesting cards in the showcases, mostly local players. I understand that local players cards are good sales here, but maybe more options in the future? For now when I look at those showcases I feel I am standing at Midwest cards but with worse displayed singles. Prices - Sealed hobby boxes are priced fairly. Singles and packs are relatively expensive comparing to other places. They do not negotiate singles price at least from what I've seen, which is completely different from my experience with them at card shows. So if you want to buy singles from them, I do recommend going to their booth at cards shows, but not at the store. Customer Service - Staff there are fine. They greeted me and asked if I need anything. However, when I asked the staff that I am interested buying a hobby box and want to pick one by myself, they refused and only want to sell the one they handed to me. This is weird and I have never had this kind of situation in other stores. Events - I like the trade night host by the store, and which they can host more in the future. Location - Limited parking spots behind the store. Usually hard to find parking spot when the store is busy or hosting events. Overall I rate this store with 2 stars. I like the store environment and the events they host, but I really hope they can improve other parts I mentioned in this review. I enjoy talking and trading with them at card shows, but the store itself is not as good as expected. I do not plan to revisit for now but look forward to a better CardCollector2.

Online Store
Games Available
Flesh and BloodSports
Opening Hours
Friday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Monday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Sunday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
KeepUp

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2025 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

Thursday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Wednesday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Customer Reviews
John Kuchmek11/3/2025

My sons and I have wanted to visit for a while and finally had the chance today. We were incredibly impressed and will definitely be back. Staff was great and took the time to explain things to my 9 year old while buying some cards from him. Great selection of both wax and singles…overall just a terrific experience.

Leonard Wennerberg
Jonathan Owens
Contact Information

3455 Grove City Road

Grove City, OH 43123

United States

(614) 991-0352
CC2_Web_OSU_1500x500_7efd33a4-cd68-4009-b926-0e4430efd74a_580x@2x.png
Visit Website
Follow:

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.

10/28/2025

This was my first time ordering from Card Collector II, and I couldn’t be happier! The entire experience, from pricing to delivery, was smooth and personal. You can tell they put real care into their products and packaging. Once I started opening my hobby box, I realized I had forgotten to order top loaders, but to my surprise, they included penny sleeves, top loaders, and a nice air freshener as gifts! I can’t even put into words how happy I was. I love supporting small businesses that clearly take pride in what they do. I’ll definitely be ordering again. Thank you so much!

9/13/2025

Ordered some cards. They got here quick, packaged well and they sent me some top loaders for free. Thank you. Great shop. Wish I lived closer do I could visit, maybe one day. P.S. I also got some really good pulls from my order Paul Skenes auto printing plate. 1/1 Jackson Chourio auto refractor 3/5 plus more! Will definitely order again.