Endless Treasure LLC

Endless Treasure LLC

3.4
(60 reviews)

Endless Treasure LLC is a trading card shop in Rensselaer, IN. They offer trading card games and hobby supplies.

Games Available

Customer Reviews

Nick EvansJul 30, 2024Google

Owner must have given discounts for 5 star reviews... most items are overpriced for their condition. Reading previous reviews I don't think that place ever got their plumbing fixed because it still smells like cat pee. The older lady running the place talked my ear off, though I didn't really want to have a conversation. Occasionally, she'd go check in on my girlfriend, making her feel as if she was being watched like she was going to steal. The cat and birds were cool though...

iBayleeJul 29, 2024Google

It smelled so strong of cat pee. Saw the cat was proof. Stuff is cute but not worth your money, and it probably has cat pee on it. It’s hard to find anything. I was scared i would turn around and break 100 items. The lady working there was friendly, not sure her name, but when a price was asked about something it was “you’ll have to come back another day so we can research it.” half of the stuff is very lived in, similar to a hoarded house, and now they’re just trying to sell what’s in it. It’s dirty, not clean. You wouldn’t want to buy an item and it be caked with dirt.

Darbji CzarneckiOct 14, 2023Google

There's a lot of stuff in there. Prices fair. But space is very tight. If you have a cane or walker or wheelchair, forget about it. I would even advise the clumsy to avoid it. It's not worth the tripping hazard. (The enter bell is also a train horn that blasts right into the customers' ears.) I do have to give them stars for being friendly, and they do have some neat stuff from time to time. But I don't think I'll ever go back.

Contact Information

1920 North McKinley Avenue

Rensselaer, IN 47978

United States

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.