Finger Lakes Sports Cards

Made the trip from Syracuse to Geneva to visit this shop and it was more than worth it! Incredible inventory and the glass case has some real gems. I have a feeling this will be the first of many trips. Nice chatting with the owner, as well.

Finger Lakes Sport Cards is a true gem for collectors! Whether you're new to the hobby or a seasoned collector, this shop has something for everyone—sealed boxes, singles, graded cards, and plenty of knowledge to go around. The staff is friendly, honest, and genuinely passionate about the hobby, which makes every visit a great experience. Their inventory is always fresh and fairly priced, and they go out of their way to help you find what you’re looking for. It's great to have a shop like this in the Finger Lakes region—supporting local collectors and the hobby in a big way!

Fingerlakes Sports Cards is inside Penny Lane, (with 2floors and a hundred ish other vendors, the rest of the non sports squad have other things to look at) main floor, center aisle second to last on your right& there’s a sign above for treasures upstairs- Steve’s thought of everything! Booth is far back enough you won’t really be bothered while looking, there’s 4 super comfortable rolling chairs so you can sit& the place plays awesome music. While there is a locked case with cards varying in prices& he just added recently a box that’s mainly $2 cards there’s also Stacks and stacks of boxes of cards that dominate the space for ONLY 50¢ each!! Don’t sleep on those. I’ve found jersey cards, ones with slivers of bats in there too. He also did this card hunt thing on his Facebook where he hid a Ted Williams card, but another guy beat me to it. I’ve spent countless hours there& always leave with something. It’s worth the drive every time. 10/10