Frankie Cirasola7/20/2025Google
First time stopping in and place was awesome. Great selection, owner was super cool and friendly. Purchased some pokemon packs and got some awesome pulls. Go check them out highly recommend !
Lost4toys
4.9
(73 reviews)Lost 4 Toys is a one stop shop for all your superhero needs! Lost 4 Toys carries all types of superhero and movie items.
Online Store
Games Available
Flesh and BloodLorcanaMagic: The GatheringPokemon
Store Hours
MondayClosed
Tuesday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Wednesday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Thursday1:00 – 8:00 PM
Friday12:00 – 6:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Customer Reviews
Emm5/25/2025Google
Lost4toys has a large selection of comics, toys, and memorabilia. Comics have a good price range from around $1-$50 depending if they are collectable. Highly recommend going here.
Cm33/16/2023Google
5 star toy store, 5 star given! This place is nothing but satisfying. Super friendly staff , prices are at the best from what i seen at any other place before! Comics, toys accessories and tv to watch while you shop lol!
Contact Information
267 Nassau Boulevard
Garden City South, NY 11530
United States
Stay Updated
Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.