Off the Rails Relics & Sports Cards

Off the Rails Relics & Sports Cards

4.8
(39 reviews)

Very nice neighborhood sports card store in Itasca, Illinois. The owner was very friendly and chatted sports with me. Nice little selection of cards naturally focusing on Chicago teams. Prices his singles reasonably, looking for recent comparable sales on eBay, which is great for a local card shop. Recommend checking them out.

Online Store

Games Available

Flesh and BloodSports

Customer Reviews

James Knudson8/21/2025Google

Very nice neighborhood sports card store in Itasca, Illinois. The owner was very friendly and chatted sports with me. Nice little selection of cards naturally focusing on Chicago teams. Prices his singles reasonably, looking for recent comparable sales on eBay, which is great for a local card shop. Recommend checking them out.

Mike K7/15/2025Google

Awesome shop! This place is a go-to for sports cards and memorabilia. They’ve got a great mix of new packs, vintage cards, and some really cool signed items. Alex who runs the shop is super friendly and always willing to help or just chat about sports. No pressure, no attitude, just a solid local shop run by a great guy. Definitely worth stopping in if you’re into cards or looking for unique sports stuff. I’ll be coming back for sure!

brian tr6/10/2025Google

*Note * they are located around the side of the building to the left once you park up front* This was my first visit and I was pleasantly surprised. Once I got inside it was clean, well organized with great lighting. Prices were fair and the owner present was friendly and engaging. Had a variety of products; raw cards, graded and sealed wax. Would recommend a stop there if you get a chance.

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.