Always looking for a shop in our travels and came across Overtime. We loved the entire store and conversation with owners and staff. Great selection of cards to thumb through and to look at in cases. Also, the ripping counter is a great place to watch others open cards and celebrate their pulls. We call this shop a destination for our family when we pass through.
Best Card Shop in Utah. They have a good selection of slabs and singles, Athlete signings, good wall of wax, breaking stations, they care about the hobby and getting kids started w packs for good school grades, etc. PSA dealer too for easy submissions. Just trust me and go here!
I absolutely love shopping at Overtime Cards! The staff is always super nice, helpful, and genuinely friendly — every time I’ve been in, they’ve made me feel appreciated and always thank me for shopping with them. Their selection of sports cards is fantastic, and while the Pokémon section is smaller, it’s still well-curated with some great finds. Their prices are more than fair — not inflated like a lot of other places. In fact, I recently picked up a PSA 10 card for only $10 that’s actually worth $18! It’s clear they care more about building good relationships with collectors than just making a sale. Overtime Cards has definitely earned my business and my five stars!
10673 South State Street
Sandy, UT 84070
United States
Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.
