The Baseball Card Store Inc

Do yourself a favor and go to Monmouth Sports cards - also in Midland Park. The people that work there are way nicer. My teenage son asked the owner of this place a simple, and fair question regarding a box of cards that said on the outside of that the box contained a mystery card, to which my 13 year old son asked a fair and thoughtful question, "what sort of mystery cards are usually included in those boxes to which the owner responded, I don't know, I didn't put the box of cards together." Whereas the owner could have just been nicer about it and said, I don't know and then left it at that. Or, he could have just made it more conversational with my son. he was standoffish and rude - to a KID! i WON'T EVER GO BACK TO THAT PLACE.

I don’t ever leave reviews… but I was so thrown off by the guys immediate standoffish character that I just had to warn people about this place. I ask the guy how much a card was going for, (to make conversation cuz it was awkward inside there), and said “Make me an offer” .. meanwhile someone else comes in and asks for the price on a different card and immediately tells them the price on it. I wouldn’t do business with this guy in terms of trading. Need something and his store has it? Buy what you need and walk out. Terrible. 0/5 stars.

Iv shopped here a few times and to be honest the workers at the store are not very friendly and i purchased two hobby boxes and one of them didn’t even have a relic or auto in the hobby box… i called another time to get prices on hobby boxes they told me they don’t tell prices over the phone so we asked why and they said we just dont and they hung up on us… we live 45 min away and didnt wanna drive if they were over charging.. we let them know we have shopped here many times before and they said they didn’t care that was our problem & proceeded to tell me that they did not need our business.(what store doesn’t want someone’s business?) I then asked if I could grab the hobby box off the shelf when I come in, why can’t you tell me a price and he responded? I just don’t. I asked to speak to the manager and he said he was the manager and he would not tell me any prices bc he doesn’t want us shopping around. (but isn’t that the point of a phone call to shop around? … i would not recommend this business to anyone to get cards at.. my girl friend call them back and they were very rude to her.. has to be new owners because it was never like this.. stay away from this place trust me