The Surprise Shop

Staff is friendly, very welcoming, and knowledgeable! They also work some great in store credit deals. And know how to make a collectors day. Last time I was in they helped a young Pokémon collector. They were looking for a scorbunni, and the owner didn't have one. He offered to do a pack battle with the young man and not only did they pull the card. Which made their day they also won the pack battle. Was great to experience!

This place is definitely somewhere you should go for anything retro. The owner definitely knows what he is talking about and is always willing to help out. The store has tons of variety from video games too vhs movies! It’s worth the drive if you’re not from Sullivan for sure. I will be shopping here again. 10/10

Amazing store! Such a variety of collectibles, toys, cards, games, you name it. Everything is extremely organized and clean. The highlight was the customer service. The nice woman working on Saturday was so sweet and patient with all the customers and all of their questions. Even letting us know about the loyalty. Would highly recommend stopping by. We will be back again and again