KeepUp
List Your Shop
AJ Collectables

AJ Collectables

4.3
(267 reviews)

The guy told me that they would purchase the sealed product I had for a certain number I requested, and he agreed to it. So I drove 25 miles to do the sale, and than the guy I talked to on phone didn’t even give me the decency to come talk to me, instead he sent me the guy that knew nothing about the deal and then after talking to the original Guy I made deal on phone with, he comes back and back pedals and offers me $45 less than original price offered. I was confused on why he lowered the original offer , when the comps matched exactly what we discussed and brought on the original offer/Agreement. Why agree to then have me drive there thinking we are good, and then do some BS and lower offer? It’s a joke! Wasted my time , and that’s probably a reason why it was dead in there, and the inventory was not a good choice. So just be more accountable to your customers and come talk and not waste peoples time!

Online Store
Games Available
Opening Hours
Friday10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Monday10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sunday10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Customer Reviews
KeepUp

Directory

  • Browse All Shops
  • Online Stores

For Businesses

  • Submit Your Shop
  • Become a Sponsor

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

KeepUp - The world's largest directory of trading card stores for Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound, and more.

© 2025 KeepUp. All rights reserved.

Scott Will
8/26/2025

The first 3 times I went in i thought the offers were low but sometimes that is the price of hobby. With no room to negotiate, I took what was available. This last trip however was beyond any low ball offer and with that, I will not return. The amount of return on their purchase will be great for them, but this is where I move on. Yes, I could have denied the offer, but then my review would not be as impactful. Thanks again guys for showing me the sad side of hobby. Sometimes we get taken, sometimes we stop it in the moment. The financial loss sucks, but the lesson has been learned. Do not recommend!

Mitchell Dassow8/14/2025

Shop has gone down hill, been to both greenfield and Hartford locations. Since the last year they’ve lost some employees that knew a ton about the hobby. I don’t see those same people and the prices on stuff in Hartford was a little crazy, I understand having to make money but a box of prizm which is 60 dollars was 120$ in their shop. Jeff who worked at greenfield was such a friendly helper as well, has been in the hobby for years upon years and had such good knowledge, sucks to see him go.

Brian Fay7/15/2022

Love this place. First time here and will definitely be coming back. Great card selections for in packs and singles. Very reasonable prices.

Contact Information

4631 South 108th Street

Greenfield, WI 53228

United States

(800) 781-2030
13e49d785d8d4f828038b6136f3b48ba@sentry.io
Visit Website

Stay Updated

Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.