Trading Card Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana
10 trading card game shops matching your criteria
Fan Cave
The second Midnight Madness of 2025 will be in June! - Trade Night - Refreshments - Special Deals - Grand Prize Giveaway - 4 $50 Gift Card Giveaways
Game Time
8244 Center Run Dr.Indianapolis, IN 46250317-577-0900 Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter Hours: Monday: 12pm – 8pmTuesday: 12pm – 8pmWednesday: 12pm – 8pmThursday: 12pm – 8pmFriday: 12pm – 10pmSaturday: 10am – 8pmSunday: Closed Submit … Posts Read More »
Good Games Indianapolis
Been there a few times now. They have an awesome selection of games and they know their MTG cards. It is always clean and organized. Parking is the only issue. Street parking is $2.35 an hour so if you're only going for a "quick" trip (lol. Quick trip to game store; NEVER), it's perfect. Sunday is free parking. That is the perfect day to take your time there.
Grandmaster Games
Grandmaster Games is a trading card shop in Indianapolis, IN. They carry Pokemon. Players can order online.
Indy Card Exchange
Have a child 13 & Under that is into collecting cards? Consider signing them up for the Indy Card Exchange Kids Club! Our goal for the club is to engage and excite the next generation of sports card collectors by sharing information about the sports card hobby and sending them down the right path to collecting safely and responsibly. It is free to join with many benefits! For more information and to register, CLICK HERE.
Mage's Comics and Games
One of the biggest, widest selection of comic books I've been to locally. Definitely one of my favorites specifically for comic books, although sometimes I'll even pick up a magic the gathering booster too. My family and I come here quite often even just to browse for fun. Staff is helpful and informative if you have questions about anything too.
Paradigm Games
Paradigm Games is a trading card shop in Indianapolis, IN. They offer trading card games and hobby supplies. Players can order online.
Saltire Toys & Games
We’ve been going to them for years for presents for our young kids as well as others. It truly feels like the games and toys for younger kids is intentionally curated to offer unique options AND they give great recommendations as well if you’re unsure about the age appropriateness of a board game or toy! Additionally, the prices are still somehow competitive with other much larger stores. Glad they’re around to offer a local option.
The Game Preserve
The mission of The Game Preserve is to delight our customers and attract new ones by operating game stores which offer outstanding selection, expertise, and organization, and which practice kindness as their most important value.
The Toy Drop
The Toy Drop store is located on the Southside of Indianapolis. The Toy Drop specializes in rare, vintage, and modern toys.